JWT vs. OAuth: Comparison and Explanation

JWT (JSON Web Token) and OAuth are two key concepts in the realm of authentication and authorization. They are often used together but serve different purposes.

JWT (JSON Web Token):
A compact, URL-safe token format used for securely transmitting information between parties as a JSON object. It can be used for both authentication and authorization.

OAuth (Open Authorization):
An authorization protocol that allows third-party applications to access a user’s resources without exposing their credentials. OAuth works with access tokens and is typically used for delegating authorization (i.e., granting access to resources).

---

Key Differences in a Comparison Table:

Aspect	JWT (JSON Web Token)	OAuth
Purpose	A token format used for transmitting claims between parties.	An authorization protocol for granting access to third-party apps.
Type	Token format (a compact string).	Protocol (defines the flow of authorization).
Primary Function	Authentication (verifies identity) and authorization (access control).	Authorization (grants access permissions to resources).
Security Model	Can be signed and optionally encrypted.	Secures access by using tokens like OAuth 2.0 access tokens.
Use Case	Ideal for stateless authentication in web applications, APIs, etc.	Best for delegated access to resources between apps/services.
Token Format	JSON Web Token (JWT).	Typically, OAuth access tokens (could be JWT or opaque tokens).
Issuer	The entity that issues the JWT.	Authorization server issues access tokens.
Audience	The parties that receive and verify the token (e.g., APIs).	The parties involved in granting access (resource owner, client, authorization server).
Expiration Handling	JWT can have an expiration (exp claim).	OAuth access tokens can expire, and refresh tokens are used to get new ones.
Token Lifespan	Defined within the token itself.	Access tokens typically have a short lifespan, refresh tokens can be used to get new access tokens.
Standards	JWT follows the standard of JWT specification (RFC 7519).	OAuth follows OAuth 2.0 specification (RFC 6749).
Implementation Complexity	Simple to implement (standalone token mechanism).	More complex as it involves several parties (resource owner, client, authorization server).

---

Detailed Example of JWT and OAuth in Action:

JWT Example:

Suppose you’re building a REST API that requires user authentication. When a user logs in, the server issues a JWT token that is returned to the client. The client then includes this token in the Authorization header of subsequent requests to authenticate the user.

1. User Logs In:
   • The user enters their credentials (username, password).
   • The server validates the credentials and generates a JWT token with claims such as the user’s ID, role, etc.
   • This JWT is signed by the server to ensure its integrity.
2. JWT is Sent to Client:
   • The server sends the JWT to the client in the response.
3. Client Makes Requests with JWT:
   • On subsequent API requests, the client includes the JWT in the Authorization header: Authorization: Bearer <JWT>.
4. Server Validates JWT:
   • The server decodes the JWT, checks its signature and expiration date, and grants access to the requested resource if valid.

OAuth Example:

OAuth is used to allow a user to give a third-party application access to certain resources without sharing their password.

1. User Wants to Allow Third-Party App Access:
   • The user clicks “Login with Google” (for instance) to grant the third-party app access to their Google Drive.
2. OAuth Flow Begins:
   • The third-party app redirects the user to Google’s authorization server.
   • Google asks the user to log in (if not already) and request permission for the third-party app to access specific resources, such as their Google Drive files.
3. Authorization Grant:
   • Once the user approves, Google sends an authorization code back to the third-party app.
4. App Requests Access Token:
   • The third-party app sends this authorization code to Google’s token endpoint.
   • Google responds with an access token (and optionally a refresh token).
5. Access Token Used to Access Resources:
   • The third-party app uses the access token to make requests to Google’s APIs (such as accessing Google Drive files).
   • If the access token expires, the third-party app can use the refresh token to get a new access token.

---

When to Use JWT and OAuth Together:

• JWT can be used in the OAuth flow to represent the access token. Once the OAuth flow is complete, the third-party app can use a JWT token as the access token to interact with the API.
• JWT ensures that the API can verify the authenticity of the access token without needing to communicate with the authorization server after the initial authentication.
• OAuth is the framework that handles the delegation of access to a user’s resources.

---

Key Takeaways:

• JWT is a format for securely transmitting claims and can be used in both authentication and authorization scenarios. It’s typically used for stateless systems like APIs.
• OAuth is a protocol used to allow third-party applications to access resources on behalf of the user without needing their credentials. It uses access tokens (often JWTs) to grant access.

Both are integral to modern web security, but their purposes and scopes are distinct yet complementary.